Skip to content
Seamless Auth Docs

Seamless Auth vs Okta

“Okta” means two product lines. Okta Workforce Identity signs employees, contractors and partners in to the apps they use at work, with a directory, lifecycle management and policy around it. Okta Customer Identity and Auth0 are Okta’s products for sign-in to the apps you build for your own customers. Seamless Auth is an open source (Apache-2.0), passwordless-only auth server that you self-host or run on the Seamless Auth managed service. Today it signs users in to applications you build, and, through its optional OpenID Provider, to other apps that speak OpenID Connect.

Most of this page compares Seamless Auth with Okta Workforce Identity, because that is what most people mean by “Okta”. Be clear about the gap first: Seamless Auth’s workforce lane (a SAML identity provider, groups and app assignment, directory sync, outbound SCIM, joiner, mover and leaver lifecycle) is planned for Seamless Auth v2.0 and is not shipped. This page compares the two as equals only where both have the feature today, and says so where Seamless Auth does not. For customer identity, see Okta Customer Identity below and the Auth0 comparison.

Every Okta detail links to Okta’s own docs, help center, trust center or pricing page, and the Sources section gives the date each one was checked. Seamless Auth details were checked against the docs and source repositories at Seamless Auth API v0.22.0 and OpenID Provider v0.3.0 on 2026-11-07. Okta changes suites and prices, so confirm them on okta.com/pricing before you decide.

Choose Okta If

Section titled “Choose Okta If”
  • You need SSO into a large catalog of SaaS apps. Okta’s app integration wizard connects SAML, OIDC, SWA (Secure Web Authentication, for apps without federation) and SCIM apps, it has a WS-Federation template app, and Okta lists 8,000+ prebuilt integrations in the Okta Integration Network. Seamless Auth’s OpenID Provider signs users in to apps that speak OpenID Connect; it has no SAML identity provider (planned for v2.0) and no integration catalog.
  • You need a workforce directory fed from HR or Active Directory. Universal Directory takes profiles from AD, LDAP and HR sources such as Workday, BambooHR and SuccessFactors, through agents you install for AD and LDAP. Seamless Auth has no directory sync (planned for v2.0).
  • You need provisioning and deprovisioning. Okta Lifecycle Management uses SCIM to create, update and deactivate accounts in apps, and deactivating a user deprovisions them. Seamless Auth has no SCIM and no lifecycle automation (SCIM server planned for v1.2, outbound SCIM and lifecycle for v2.0).
  • You need policy and device checks. Global session policies, app sign-in policies and device assurance policies have no Seamless Auth equivalent. Seamless Auth has instance sign-in settings, such as phishing_resistant_only, and step-up for sensitive actions, not a policy engine over users, devices and context.
  • You need desktop, network or server access. Okta Device Access (Desktop MFA at the macOS and Windows login screens), the RADIUS agent, the LDAP Interface and Okta Privileged Access are outside what Seamless Auth does. RADIUS, LDAP and forward-auth are planned for v2.1.
  • You need governance. Okta Identity Governance combines Lifecycle Management, Workflows and Access Governance. Seamless Auth has none of these.
  • You need a vendor’s compliance reports. Okta’s trust center lists FedRAMP High and Moderate, DoD IL5, SOC 1, 2 and 3, ISO/IEC 27001, 27017 and 27018, HIPAA, PCI DSS, GovRAMP and others. Seamless Auth has no third-party attestations of its own.

Choose Seamless Auth If

Section titled “Choose Seamless Auth If”
  • Users and sessions must stay inside your own boundary. Self-hosted, the auth API and its Postgres database run in your infrastructure, on any cloud or none. Okta documents agents and an Access Gateway appliance that you install yourself, but the Okta service itself runs in Okta’s cells; it documents no self-hosted deployment of it.
  • You want the auth server’s source under a permissive license. The auth API, OpenID Provider, server adapters, frontend SDKs, admin dashboard and CLI are all Apache-2.0. Okta is a commercial service sold as suites.
  • You want passkeys as the default and passwords gone. Seamless Auth has no password flow, and phishing_resistant_only accepts only passkeys to start a session. Okta supports passwordless too: passkeys (FIDO2 WebAuthn) and Okta FastPass are its phishing-resistant authenticators, and passwords can be made optional or disabled per group. Okta’s docs note that LDAP users are not supported for that, and that traditional RADIUS does not work with passwordless users.
  • You do not want a per-user contract. Self-hosting has no per-user fee and no minimum; you pay for the infrastructure you run. Okta Workforce Identity suites are priced per user per month, billed annually, with a $1,500 annual contract minimum.
  • You want your audit trail for as long as you keep it. Seamless Auth’s auth events are append-only and hash-chained rows in your own Postgres, and they export as NDJSON with an integrity check. Okta retains System Log events for 90 days, and log streaming goes to Amazon EventBridge or Splunk Cloud.
  • You want your user data out without asking. Self-hosted, users and memberships are rows in a database you run. Okta exports user profiles through the Users API or a CSV report; a password hash export is possible only in a very limited number of cases, by request, for a move from Okta to Auth0.
  • What you need is sign-in for an app your team builds. An adapter for Node.js, Go, Python or Rust and a frontend SDK is a shorter path than a workforce identity platform. Seamless Auth also covers some internal-app sign-in today: Grafana or an internal tool behind oauth2-proxy can sign in through its OpenID Provider.

Feature Comparison: Okta Workforce Identity

Section titled “Feature Comparison: Okta Workforce Identity”

Okta column as checked on the dates in Sources. Suite names refer to Okta’s pricing page. Where the Seamless Auth column says Planned, the feature does not exist today.

Seamless Auth Okta Workforce Identity
License Apache-2.0 for the server, OpenID Provider, SDKs, dashboard and CLI Commercial cloud service, sold as suites
Hosting Self-host (Docker, Postgres) or Seamless Auth managed hosting Okta-operated cells; customer-installed AD, LDAP and RADIUS agents and Access Gateway
Passkeys Yes, the primary sign-in method (WebAuthn via SimpleWebAuthn) Yes, the Passkey (FIDO2 WebAuthn) authenticator
Phishing-resistant authenticators Passkeys; phishing_resistant_only accepts only passkeys to start a session Passkey (FIDO2 WebAuthn), Okta Verify with FastPass, smart card (PIV/CAC), custom authenticators
Other authenticators Magic link, email OTP, SMS OTP (Twilio or AWS SNS, configured by you), TOTP Okta Verify (push and TOTP), password, email, phone (SMS and voice, through your own telephony provider), Google Authenticator, YubiKey OTP, Duo, Symantec VIP, custom OTP, security question, temporary access code
Passwords No, by design Yes; optional or disabled per group, not for LDAP users
SSO into third-party apps OpenID Connect only, through the OpenID Provider (v0.21, off by default, not OpenID certified); tested guides for Grafana, Auth.js, Spring Security and oauth2-proxy SAML, OIDC, SWA, WS-Federation (template app, SP-initiated); 8,000+ prebuilt integrations
SAML identity provider Planned for v2.0 Yes
Directory, groups, app assignment, app launcher Planned for v2.0. Users, global roles and organizations exist today Universal Directory, groups, app assignment
Directory and HR sources Planned for v2.0 (Google Workspace and Entra ID) AD and LDAP agents; HR and other profile sources such as Workday, BambooHR, SuccessFactors
Provisioning to apps (outbound SCIM) Planned for v2.0 Lifecycle Management, in Essentials or as an add-on to Starter
Inbound provisioning CSV import and seamless migrate; SCIM server planned for v1.2 Profile sourcing from HR apps and directories
Lifecycle automation Planned for v2.0 Lifecycle Management, Workflows, Okta Identity Governance
Policy Instance sign-in settings, staged sign-in policy, step-up Global session policy, app sign-in policies, device assurance
Roles and permissions in the token Organization membership roles today. A permission catalogue, role-to-permission mapping and organization roles in the token need API v0.23.0, which is not released Custom authorization servers with scopes and claims (API Access Management)
Tokens for your own APIs Yes, through the OpenID Provider: authorization code with S256 PKCE, client credentials, device grant (first-party), RFC 9068 JWT access tokens Custom authorization servers, which need the API Access Management add-on; client credentials; built-in org authorization server in every org
Extensibility Logic in your own backend, behind the server adapter. Webhooks and login hooks are planned for v0.23 Inline hooks (synchronous), event hooks (asynchronous, up to 25 per org), Okta Workflows (5 in Starter, 50 in Essentials)
Desktop, RADIUS and LDAP access Planned for v2.1 (RADIUS, LDAP, forward-auth) Okta Device Access (Desktop MFA for macOS and Windows), RADIUS agent, LDAP Interface
Audit trail Append-only, hash-chained auth events; NDJSON export with an integrity check System Log, 90 days; log streaming to Amazon EventBridge or Splunk Cloud
User export No bulk export endpoint; self-hosted, the data is in your own Postgres. Paginated admin user list and a passkey coverage report (CSV) Users API, User Accounts report as CSV; password hashes only in limited cases, by request, for a move to Auth0
Third-party compliance attestations None for Seamless Auth itself FedRAMP High and Moderate, DoD IL5, SOC 1/2/3, ISO/IEC 27001, 27017, 27018, HIPAA, and others on Okta’s trust center
Maturity 0.x, small community Established commercial product, large community
Pricing model Free to self-host; managed plans in the portal Suites per user per month, billed annually, $1,500 annual minimum; free Integrator plan for non-production use, up to 10 active users

Okta Customer Identity

Section titled “Okta Customer Identity”

Okta sells customer identity two ways. Okta’s site lists Auth0 and Okta Customer Identity under customer identity, and okta.com/customer-identity redirects to auth0.com. Okta Customer Identity is priced on its own tab of Okta’s pricing page: it starts with a required Enterprise base product at $3,000 per month, billed annually, with add-ons priced by usage such as monthly active users, and B2C and B2B suites on inquiry, all on an annual contract.

For a feature-by-feature comparison of customer identity, read the Auth0 comparison, which covers Auth0 as sold on auth0.com, and confirm the features of an Okta Customer Identity plan with Okta. The Identity Cost Calculator lists published prices for both.

Architecture Difference

Section titled “Architecture Difference”

Okta is a central identity provider for an organization. Apps are assigned to users and groups in the Okta org and redirect them to the org’s sign-in page. Okta evaluates the global session policy and the app’s sign-in policy, authenticates the user with the required authenticators, and returns a SAML assertion or OpenID Connect tokens. Users, groups and app assignments live in the Okta org, fed by directories and HR sources, and you manage them in the Admin Console or through Okta’s APIs.

Seamless Auth is a service you run next to your backend:

browser or native app
  -> your backend's /auth routes   (@seamless-auth/express, fastify, nextjs, or the Python/Go/Rust adapter)
  -> seamless-auth-api             (your infrastructure, or Seamless Auth managed)
  -> Postgres

Clients never call the auth API directly. Your backend mounts the adapter routes, forwards calls with a service token, and keeps the session in signed httpOnly cookies on your domain (native apps use bearer tokens in the platform keystore). Authorization stays in your own code. See What Is Seamless Auth?.

Since v0.21 you can also run the optional OpenID Provider, a separate public service in front of the private API. Apps that speak OpenID Connect redirect to its hosted pages and get tokens back the way they would from Okta, with no Seamless SDK. That covers some internal-app sign-in today. It is not a workforce identity platform: there is no SAML, no group-based app assignment, and no provisioning.

The two also work together. Seamless Auth can use an Okta org as an upstream OpenID Connect provider through OAuth Login, so employees sign in with their Okta account while your app gets a Seamless session.

When Not To Use Seamless Auth

Section titled “When Not To Use Seamless Auth”

If any of these is a hard requirement today, stay on Okta or choose another product.

  • You need to sign employees in to SAML apps or a SaaS catalog. Seamless Auth has no SAML identity provider (planned for v2.0) and no integration catalog.
  • You provision or deprovision accounts from HR or a directory. There is no SCIM, no directory sync and no lifecycle automation. Bulk changes go through the CSV import.
  • You rely on sign-in policies, device assurance or governance. Seamless Auth has no equivalent.
  • You need desktop MFA, RADIUS or LDAP. Out of scope today; RADIUS, LDAP and forward-auth are planned for v2.1.
  • You need permissions in the token now. That needs API v0.23.0, which is not released.
  • Other apps need a certified identity provider. The OpenID Provider is new and not OpenID certified.
  • You need a vendor’s FedRAMP authorization or SOC 2 report for the auth service itself. Seamless Auth has no third-party attestations. Self-hosted, it is covered by your own controls.
  • Your users sign in with passwords and you cannot change that. There is no password flow, and no password hashes are imported.
  • You need a 1.0 stability guarantee. Every Seamless Auth package is still 0.x.

The full list is in When Seamless Auth Is Not The Right Choice.

Moving An App’s Users Off Okta

Section titled “Moving An App’s Users Off Okta”

There is no dedicated Okta source in seamless migrate yet. Export users with Okta’s Users API or the User Accounts report as CSV, then import them with seamless migrate csv, after a readiness check with seamless migrate assess csv. See Migrate Users From Another Identity System. This path is not tested against an Okta export.

No credentials move. During cutover, imported users can keep signing in with their Okta account through OpenID Connect, then enroll a passkey (sign in through the old provider). This moves an app’s users, not an organization’s workforce identity: Okta stays the directory for everything else.

Sources

Section titled “Sources”

Okta details, each checked on 2026-11-07 on Okta’s own pages:

Not verified, so not claimed on this page: prices of Workforce add-ons and of the Professional and Enterprise suites (Okta publishes none), an Okta statement that the service is cloud-only, whether the cell list on the data residency page is current, the scope of FedRAMP High beyond Okta for Government, and how SWA stores credentials.

Seamless Auth details (Seamless Auth API v0.22.0, OpenID Provider v0.3.0, checked 2026-11-07):

Part of the Fells Code family
Seamless AuthSeamless SecretsReview BoardSeamless CLISeamless Glance